A new class action accuses Pottery Barn and West Elm of using exaggerated original prices to mislead shoppers.

Four California shoppers filed a class action lawsuit against Williams-Sonoma Inc. and its subsidiary Williams-Sonoma Stores Inc. in California federal court on Nov. 6, 2026.

The plaintiffs claim the company shows inflated crossed-out prices at Pottery Barn, Pottery Barn Kids, Pottery Barn Teen and West Elm to make everyday prices look like limited-time deals.

How the alleged fake discounts work

Across its websites, stores and emails, the company pairs a crossed-out regular price with a lower price, often with a sale, clearance or limited-time-offer label, the proposed class action claims. To a shopper, that signals a temporary markdown, according to the lawsuit.

The complaint alleges the lower price is actually the item's normal price and that the higher one rarely, if ever, reflects what Williams-Sonoma sells the item for. California law bars retailers from advertising a former price unless it was the going price within the previous three months or the ad clearly states when it was.

The lawsuit also faults promotional emails that push big discounts with urgent deadlines, such as a West Elm sale that ran a day past its stated end.

Examples from the plaintiffs' purchases

Krista Zizzo claims she paid $1,707 for a Pottery Barn desk in November 2024. The site called it a limited-time offer and showed a $1,897 regular price. Two years later, the desk allegedly still showed the same label.

Emerson Melo alleges he paid $54.97 for a West Elm duvet cover with a crossed-out $189 price. The complaint says West Elm showed the same deal weeks before he bought it and still showed it more than a year later.

The legal claims

Williams-Sonoma faces five claims:


  • False Advertising Law, which prohibits misleading ads, including fake former prices

  • Unfair Competition Law, which covers unfair and deceptive business practices

  • Consumers Legal Remedies Act, which targets deceptive sales practices

  • Intentional misrepresentation and fraudulent concealment, which prevents companies from knowingly misleading shoppers

  • Negligent misrepresentation, which addresses careless false statements

All five claims cover both the nationwide class and the California subclass.

The plaintiffs seek refunds of what buyers overpaid plus compensatory and punitive damages. They also request a court order that stops Williams-Sonoma from showing fake regular prices.

What this means for shoppers

The proposed class includes anyone in the United States who bought an item on sale from Pottery Barn, Pottery Barn Kids, Pottery Barn Teen or West Elm in the past four years. A California subclass covers purchases in the state.

There is no settlement, no claims process and no money available at this time.