
On Nov. 6, Jennifer Durning filed a class action lawsuit against L'Oréal USA, which owns Kiehl's, in California federal court.
She claims two Kiehl's skincare products that carry an oil-free label contain several ingredients that qualify as oils.
The products at issue
The proposed class action targets two skincare products that Kiehl's sells online and in stores across the United States with "oil-free" on the front label:
- Kiehl's Ultra Facial Oil-Free Gel Face Cream
- Kiehl's Ultra Facial Oil-Free Cleanser
The complaint defines an oil as any substance that repels water and attracts fats, a group it says includes silicones, esters and fatty acids. It claims the Kiehl's products include ingredients such as:
- Dimethicone and dimethiconol, silicones it calls polar oils
- Isononyl isononanoate, an ester with an oil-like feel on the skin
- Stearic, palmitic, myristic and lauric acids, which are fatty acids
- Tocopheryl acetate, a form of vitamin E that can come from vegetable oil
Why shoppers allegedly miss the oils
The lawsuit alleges average shoppers cannot spot these ingredients as oils without a chemistry background. Citing grocery-shopping studies, the filing claims only 7.7%-11.6% of shoppers look past the front label and that most make in-store decisions in about 13 seconds.
The class action also points to one-star reviews on Kiehl's website in which shoppers say the products left their skin shiny or oily.
Kiehl's repeats the oil-free claim on its website and on other retailers' sites, according to the complaint. It also alleges Durning bought Kiehl's Ultra Facial Oil-Free Gel Face Cream because of that label and would not have bought it, or would have paid much less, had she known about the oil ingredients.
The legal claims
The lawsuit brings seven claims:
- Unfair Competition Law, which bars unfair and deceptive business practices
- False Advertising Law, which prohibits misleading ads
- Consumers Legal Remedies Act, which bans deceptive sales practices
- Breach of express warranty for failing to deliver what the label promises
- Unjust enrichment, which seeks to recover money a company gained unfairly
- Intentional misrepresentation for knowingly making false claims
- Negligent misrepresentation for making false claims without good reason to believe them
The first four cover California buyers while the last three cover buyers nationwide. Durning seeks the extra money buyers paid, punitive damages and a court order that requires L'Oréal to change the labels.
Who the lawsuit covers
The proposed class covers anyone in the United States who bought either product in the past four years. There is no settlement, no claims process and no money available at this time.
.png)







.webp)
.webp)
.webp)

.webp)
.webp)
.webp)
.webp)



