Frontier Insurance Labor Depreciation Settlement

Eligible Frontier policyholders may claim payments from a class action settlement over labor depreciation deductions in Illinois.

Frontier Insurance Labor Depreciation Settlement
Updated on
Published on

Settlement Terms

  • Status:
  • Award:
  • Is Proof Required?
  • Claim Deadline:
    December 15, 2023
    Not Set
  • Days Left to File Claim:
  • Settlement Amount:
  • Final Approval:
    October 26, 2023
Settlement summaries by Claim Depot are written for people who might be eligible to claim class action settlement awards. Our goal is to provide the reader all relevant information about the settlement so they can claim their lawsuit funds. Claim Depot uses artificial intelligence (AI) to extract data from the vast amounts of text on the Official Settlement Website and in the court documents. Then, our writers, who are licensed attorneys, write the summary in plain English so the greater public can better understand their rights.


Who Benefits?: All policyholders under any Commercial or Personal Lines property insurance policy issued by Frontier, who made a Structural Loss claim for property located in the State of Illinois during the applicable Class Periods.

How much can I get?: Payments vary, with the average estimated to be $1,722.06 for most Class Members and approximately $60.40 for "interest only" Class Members.

Detailed Analysis of the Settlement Amount

The settlement reached in the class action lawsuit against Frontier-Mt Carroll Mutual Insurance addresses the alleged improper deduction of labor depreciation from insureds' actual cash value payments when adjusting certain insurance claims in Illinois. The settlement aims to compensate those who were affected by these deductions.

The compensation structure has been carefully designed to ensure fairness and adequacy. For Class Members who complete and sign a Claim Form and timely mail it to the proper address, or submit the Claim Form by uploading it on the Settlement Website, may be eligible for a payment. The settlement offers 112.5% of the net estimated labor depreciation that was withheld and not subsequently paid. This also reflects a commitment to not only reimburse but also acknowledge the inconvenience caused.

Important Dates

  • Fairness Hearing: October 26, 2023
  • Deadline to File a Claim: December 15, 2023

Who Are the Class Members?

Class Members are defined as those who held a property insurance policy with Frontier and made a claim for structural loss within Illinois during the Class Period, which spans from February 28, 2020, to September 17, 2021. These claims must have resulted in an actual cash value payment from which labor depreciation was deducted or would have resulted in a payment if not for the deduction causing the loss to fall below the deductible.

  • Policyholders with Structural Loss claims
  • Policyholders with Covered Loss claims

Exclusions apply to policyholders whose claims were under policy forms that expressly permitted labor depreciation deductions or whose claims exhausted the insurance limits, among others.

Settlement Awards Details

Class Members who submit a valid and timely claim form may be eligible for a payment. The settlement provides two tiers of payments. For most Class Members, the payment is calculated at 112.5% of the net estimated labor depreciation. For those who recovered all outstanding labor depreciation through the claims process, a one-time payment of 2.5% to 10% of the initially withheld amount is offered, depending on the duration of the withholding.

  • Majority of Class Members: 112.5% of net estimated labor depreciation
  • "Interest Only" Class Members: One-time payment ranging from 2.5% to 10%

Subject of the Settlement

The settlement specifically addresses the deduction of labor depreciation from payments for covered structural loss claims under Frontier's property insurance policies in Illinois.

  • Deduction of labor depreciation
  • Structural loss claims

Is Proof Required to Claim the Reward?

Claimants will need to submit a completed and signed Claim Form, potentially with additional proof of legal representation if filing on behalf of a deceased or incapacitated Class Member or proof of claim assignment if filed by a contractor.

Why Is There a Class Action Settlement?

The class action settlement arises from allegations that Frontier-Mt Carroll Mutual Insurance did not properly handle the depreciation of labor costs in certain insurance claims. The settlement is a result of negotiations between the parties aimed at compensating affected policyholders without the need for protracted litigation. Claimants are encouraged to submit their claims by the deadline to receive their due compensation.

Case Facts

  • Case Number:
  • Filing Date:
  • Jurisdiction:
  • State:
  • Court:
  • Plaintiff:
  • Defendant:
    Frontier-Mt Carroll Mutual Insurance
  • Plaintiff Firm:
    Butsch Roberts & Associates LLC. and Byron Carslon Petri & Kalb LLC
  • Claims Admin:
    Atticus Administration PO Box 64053 St. Paul, MN 55164 1-800-227-7163
  • Defendant Firm:
Kasia Nelson
Kasia Nelson
Reporter and Licensed Attorney
Weekly newsletter

Stay up to date with new class action settlements you may join.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Apply Now

Settlement Agreement

This browser does not support inline PDFs. Please download the PDF to view it: Download PDF

Settlement Agreement

This browser does not support inline PDFs. Please download the PDF to view it: Download PDF

Related class action Settlements

Read more to get notified about updates to each settlement.

Visa Mastercard $5.54 Billion Interchange Fee Settlement
Open for Claims

Visa Mastercard $5.54 Billion Interchange Fee Settlement

Up to 1% of total Visa/MasterCard revenue
Theranos Inc. Settlement
Open for Claims

Theranos Inc. Settlement

$10 - $1,000
Boohoo Group  Settlement: Award: $10 Gift Card
Open for Claims

Boohoo Group Settlement: Award: $10 Gift Card

$10 Gift Card with Free Shipping